NY Times best selling author and marketing expert Roy Williams (and one of my closest friends) writes this about why advertising fails from his book The Wizard of Ads: Turning Words into Magic and Dreamers into Millionaires
. This book is a must read for anyone who wants to market a product.
I've added MY comments under each of his thoughts.
1. The
desire for instant gratification. The ad which creates
sufficient urgency to cause people to respond immediately is also
the ad most likely to be forgotten immediately following the
‘expiration’ of the offer. Such ads are of little use
in establishing an identity for the advertiser in the mind of the
consumer.
Eric: This is the trap many fall into. They think they can run one ad and the world will come to their door when in reality people first need to be comfortable knowing you before beating your door down. This requires frequent impressions over time.
2.
Attempting to reach more people than the budget will allow. For
a ‘media mix’ to be effective, each element in the mix
must have sufficient repetition to establish ‘retention’
in the mind of the prospect. Too often, however, the result of a
media mix is too much reach, not enough frequency. Will you reach
100% of the people and convince them 10% of the way? Or will you
reach 10% of the people and convince them 100% of the way? The
cost is the same.
Eric: Our egos tell us we need to be everywhere, but just like dividing our time across too many things, nothing gets done well. Focus is always more powerful and effective. If your ads work and you make more money you can always spread out later.
3.
Assuming the business owner knows best. The business owner is
uniquely unqualified to see his company or his product objectively.
He is on the inside looking out, trying to describe himself to a
person on the outside looking in. It's hard to read the label when
you’re inside the bottle. Too much product knowledge causes
the business owner to answer questions no one is asking. This makes
for extremely ineffective advertising.
Eric: Clients are typically too close to their product. They are overly sensitive to the objections they hear in the market or to their competitors and often want to overcome those issues at their own top of mind. An outsider can help you focus on what really matters ... selling product.
4.
Unsubstantiated claims such as “highest quality at the lowest
price”. Advertisers will often claim to have what the
customer wants, but fail to offer any evidence. A cliché is
nothing less than an unsubstantiated claim the public is tired of
hearing. You must prove what you say in every ad. The prospect
will not make a new decision about your product until you have given
him new information and new perspective. Do your ads supply new
information? Do they provide a new perspective? If not, prepare to
be disappointed with the results.
Eric: We are numb to these words. Wah wah wah. Give me something everyone else does not say. In art everyone wants to be "The painter of...." because Kincaid used "Painter of Light".
5.
Improper use of passive media. Non-intrusive media, such as
newspaper and yellow pages, require the use of reticular activator
(such as a photo or illustration) because passive media tends to
reach only those buyers who are actively in the market for the
product. Passive media is very poor at reaching prospects prior to
their need, which means it is extremely difficult for passive media
to create a predisposition towards your company. With patience, the
consistent use of intrusive media (such as radio and television)
will win the heart of the customer before he is in the market for
the product.
Eric: My goal is to help you know how to use passive media with the use of images and words to make it work, since there is no radio or tv in the art world.
6.
Creating ads instead of campaigns. It is foolish to believe a
single ad can ever tell the entire story. The most effective,
persuasive and memorable ads are those most like a rhinoceros. They
will each make a single point very powerfully. An advertiser with
seventeen different things to say should commit to a campaign of at
least seventeen different ads, with each ad being given sufficient
repetition to accomplish retention in the mind of the prospect.
Eric: Advertising is a process not a single event. Coke is the top brand but they never stop visibility.
7.
Obedience to unwritten rules. For some insane reason,
advertisers want their ads to look and sound like ads. Why is this?
Eric: This is so true in the art world. All gallery and artist ads look alike. Name at the top, image, logo. No headlines, no copy to sell. One needs to be different to stand out. Why follow the pack?
8.
Late week schedules. Advertisers justify their unreasonable
focus on Thursday and Friday advertising with the statement, “We
need to reach the customer just before he goes shopping”. Why
do these advertisers choose to compete for the prospect’s
attention each Thursday and Friday when they can have a nice, quiet
chat all alone with the prospect each Sunday, Monday and Tuesday?
Eric: The real point of this is that you need to be consistent continuously.
9.
Overconfidence in qualitative targeting. The importance of
qualitative data has been grossly overestimated by many advertisers
and media professionals. In reality, Saying The Wrong Thing
has killed far more ad campaigns than Reaching The Wrong People.
It is amazing how many people become “the right people”,
when you are saying the right thing.
Eric: Every media has an audience who can buy if you know how to speak to that audience.
10.
Event driven Marketing. A special event should be judged only
by its ability to help you more clearly define your market position
and substantiate your claims. If one percent of the people who hear
your ad for a special event actually choose to come, you will be in
desperate need of a traffic cop and a bus to shuttle people from
remote parking lots. Yet your real investment will be in the 99%
who did not come to the event! What did your ad say to them?
Eric: In art we focus a lot on events. An artist friend spent a week at a "must do" show. He had travel and hotel expense, and a week of his time painting. The event over the weekend maybe had 150 people to buy from 60 artists. Sales were low and in his case nothing was sold. Had he taken the $1000 he spent to attend this event and used it for marketing to reach ten's of thousands of people he would have a bigger chance of selling more artwork and reaching 100x more people.
11.
Great production without great copy. Too many ads today are
creative without being persuasive. “Slick, clever, funny,
creative and different” are poor substitutes for “informative,
believable, memorable and persuasive”.
Eric: Bottom line. Does your message cut through and get your point across?
12.
Confusing “response” with “results”.
The goal of advertising is to create a clear awareness of your
company and its Unique Selling Proposition. Unfortunately, most
advertisers evaluate their ads by the comments they hear from the
people around them. The slickest, cleverest, funniest, most
creative and most different ads are the ones most likely to generate
these comments. See the problem? When we confuse “Response”
with “Results” we create “attention getting ads”
which say absolutely nothing.
Eric: Its important to start your marketing with "What do I want to accomplish?" and "How will I measure success?" and "What do I need to do to accomplish my goals." Most people only simply are not advertising experts and as a result don't know how it works and how to make it works and as a result their expectations are not met.